The Appraisal

Today I received my appraisal to “review and sign”.
It was not a task I was looking forward to: putting my name to a document that had clearly been drafted by an incompetent dinosaur who couldn’t ‘manage’ a piss up in a brewery.

Not only had one of my “notable achievements” been the successful typing up of a report (wow, thanks!), but I had also managed to competently organise the keys in the key cupboard.

Now, if that was all I’d done, fair enough. Or even if I’d made a complete pigs ear of everything else. But that’s the problem when you work for a dinosaur. They don’t notice things that they can’t do themselves. They can’t understand how it’s saved someone several hours a week, or hundreds of pounds.

For example. The code I wrote to format the useless expenses spreadsheets I get sent. Or the whole review of our contracts and suppliers to make sure we were getting the best deals.

Why didn’t I mention this in my appraisal meeting? Well I did. But this hideous document had already been written. And it was hard enough for me explaining how to put a watermark onto a word document. Let alone trying to explain what code is. 

So what should you do in this scenario? I personally did nothing. I was confident enough in my own abilities to know that keeping quiet would save me a lot of hassle. Arguing with a Dinosaur is pointless. After realising they are in the wrong, they will ultimately just pull rank on you and you’ll have to agree with them anyway. So I saved myself about half an hour of pain, and used that time to start looking for another job.

But if you are at the start of your career, an episode like that can really throw you. It will make you start to question your ability. My advice would be to suck it up, and then when you are away from the office, personally evaluate what has been said. Be critical. Could you have submitted that report any quicker? Should you have suggested a better way of doing something when you knew a better way? You don’t have to discuss it with anyone, but really think about it. If you think that perhaps you could have done better, start doing better! Think about where you are in your career. Is organising a key cupboard really an achievement? If it is, then great.
Finally, think about if you care about your appraisal. 9 times out of 10 you really should. If you think your boss’s criticism has been fair, go and ask him what you need to do in order to get a better one next time. A good boss will be able to give you reasonable pointers on how to improve. Take them on board and do them so that he notices that you are heeding to advice and genuinely want to do better. A bad boss will just tell you to work harder or “do better”. If he says this, you are likely to get the same old story next time around. A boss like this probably gives bad appraisals with no improvement advice so that he doesn’t have to pay you a bonus. Trust me, I’ve been there, and it never gets better. My advice here would be to start looking for a better boss.

What is your boss like with appraisals? Does he or she offer constructive advice? Do they just fob you off? What is the most helpful advice you have ever been given about an appraisal?


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s